The same rules with respect to interstate sales that are applicable to sales and purchases of other tangible personal property also apply to sales of coins, silver and gold bullion, and other precious metals. They come from abandoned safe deposit boxes held by financial institutions, evidence from police departments, and various other entities such as colleges, hospitals and nursing homes. I bring up 408 only because nowhere else, aside from Sec 613 (percentage depletion), will you find the word "Gold" in the IRC. There needs to be a beneficiary named to receive the remaining funds at termination of the trust. The rules and laws pertaining to the possession and transfer of Asian Ivory is detailed and complex. Obviously, if the coins in the RR did not acquire any "collector's value," then the RR would have had to address that fact and would have been worded completely different. This is especially true when the beneficiaries of ones residuary estate are intended to be different than the beneficiaries of ones tangible personal property. Listed personal property is a type of personal use property. platinum, gold, or silver bullion having a total value of $1,000 or more; . Assume that the trustee is able to sell the bullion a few days later. And you're only talking about those state that actually impose a tax. The Comptroller treats the sale of software, canned or custom, as the taxable sale of tangible . They have value only because of their gold content. What matters is the value of the property. Maybe I would label it: "Property other than money that is not tangible personalty for purposes of Section 170 of the Code." You persist in missing my point. Not sure how. The best you might do with this argument is avoid preparer penalties. Depending on the item, the nature of your business, when the item was purchased and other factors, you may be taxed on the fair market value of your TPP. More advanced planning can involve the use of gun trusts as owners for NFA guns to avoid transfer restrictions. That, by the way is my position. A letter from the property appraisal office will usually be sent by mail to the company notifying it to file taxes on its property. Janet Berry-Johnson is a CPA with 10 years of experience in public accounting and writes about income taxes and small business accounting. (Allowed only when the bullion is sold. The term includes articles even if held for investment purposes and encompasses tangible property . Goodman Law | Attorney Advertising, 14 Ridgedale Avenue, Suite 254, Cedar Knolls, NJ 07927 | Phone: 973.567.3849, Legal Blog For Elder Law and Estate Planning In New Jersey, Estate Planning Questions About Tangible Personal Property, Elder Law From an Estate Planning Perspective, The Difference Between Executors, Trustees, and Guardians, Avoiding the Pitfalls of Trust and Estate Administration, Divorced Parents with Special Needs Children, Estate Lawyer Planning for Solo Boomers, Estate Planning: Telling your Children What Youre Planning and Why. For charitable purposes, if treated as "property" (i.e. Tangible assets are physical and measurable assets that are used in a company's operations. Then comes the law. Who knows? Some page levels are currently hidden. Contributions of gold mining stock or shares in an ETF that invests in gold mines are treated the same way as any contribution of stock: if held more than one year, the donors charitable deduction will be based on the fair market value of the stock on the day of donation; if held one year or less it will be based on the donors cost basis in the stock. Likewise, I wouldn't bet the farm on your "out of context" estate tax rulings, as I mentioned above. Per Rev Rul 69-63 the IRS ruled that gold coins that do not have any numismatic value are more akin to money that therefore are not considered tangible personal property for donation purposes. Might want to read this too, about how uber important state law characterization is with respect to 1031 exchanges Held, since the collection of rare coins was not held primarily as a medium of exchange. You conveniently left out of the parts about (1) the coins being rare and (2) the coins acquiring value as collector's items. I would think closer to behind the eight ball, but I certainly don't disagree that the PLR can be relied on to avoid penalties. That is code specific. and there is no way you can either make a currency distinction between US and Canadian coins. 120, par. In fact, 43 states use an appraised TPP value when calculating state taxes on personal property, business . See Treas. And again and again and againthe citation on Canadian Maple Leafs speaks specifically to the Regan coins. General consensus is that PLR 9225036 was about to be reversed by another PLR that was not issued because the applicant died and that it is unlikely it would hold. If its deemed to be tangible personal property, then you can just gift it via a separate list, without the need for witnesses or a notary. We'd like to know about Section 170. platinum, gold, or silver bullion having a total value of $1,000 or more; . GCM 33791 was issued in 1968, before the basis limitation rule of IRC 170(e)(3)(B) was enacted in the Tax Reform Act of 1969 (P.L. I couldn't. That you feel a deduction under 170 would be disallowed if it were made in foreign currency? Rul. The gold and silver coins clearly are tangible property, in that they can be felt or touched. No net deduction. Therefore, sales of such coins for delivery in Massachusetts are subject to the Massachusetts sales or use tax. If you actually read what Dave wrote, he was speaking about "guidance"as in cases, rulings, and the like. Legal Tender. Rev. 5703-9-46(A)(7) do differ somewhat on the treatment of "customized" software. Basically, the guy sold his land on a tax-free basis. Sure would be nice, by the way,if you could find some kind of opinion supporting the logic of the PLR. Your position then is that my example stands. Gold coins are more akin to stock than a publicly traded ETF holding bullion. In addition, and this includes a gift of shares in a gold bullion ETF, the donor will need to file a Form 8283 that describes the gift. You can't extend the logic b/c the RR logic applies to the specific coins involved in the ruling. Also, because the coins have both intrinsic and marketable value, in and of themselves, they cannot be considered intangible property, without more. Experienced Estate Planning Attorney, Elga A. Goodman, can help you with all your estate planning needs. Household furnishings, books, tools, jewelry, motor vehicles and boats are some of the items which fall into the category of tangible personal property. Suppose that instead of contributing the bullion outright, Mr. Franklin contributed it in exchange for a gift annuity. South African Krugerrand gold coins are one of the best known types of gold bullion coins. It can be valued just as easily, you just weigh it instead of looking it up on a stock chart. Each evidences something else. The IRS concluded that South African Krugerrand gold bullion coins were not personal property for purposes of IRC 170(a)(3). Please remove any contact information or personal data from your feedback. I see no difference between a donation of gold and a donation of diamonds. They've just said it's property other than money. My mind is closed from the standpoint that I do not believe we should always apply old paradigms to new issues. Ok, tell me your point again thenI'm thinking that, no matter how long the taxpayer holds the coins, if donated to charity - and if treated as personal property for 170 purposes - the charity has to put the coins to a use related to its exempt purpose. It just fleshed out the history of the cases and the facts, with a few observations here and there. 7) A. Related Professionals. Outright gift of gold bullion If the courts want the "circulating" test, then by all means, let's flesh it out. Thus they appear to be USC Title 37 5112(a)(7) coins. I'm afraid you will not find one, which leaves the issue unresolved. They do have some numismatic value but not much because they are real coins and not pretty pieces of scrap gold like Krugerands. The charitable deduction is computed using Decembers 1.6% IRS discount rate. Even though the courts constructed the "circulation" test, the minute they see it falls flat when the U.S. started minted coins again, they'll toss the test out the window and come up with a new one to twist the rules (yet again). I tend to think an American gold coin, legal tender, like the OP's gold coin, is more akin to an appreciated stock than a painting. Any other tangible personal property that the IRS determines is a "collectible" under IRC Section 408 (m). These assets can be held by both individuals and corporations. Go find a charity that will take your position. First, here is what you wrote: Rev. Tangible property is physical assets such as collectible coins, jewelry, military medals, stamps, antiques, savings bonds or other physical items. For purpose of 2001. Average Retirement Savings: How Do You Compare? Investopedia does not include all offers available in the marketplace. Precious metals can be bought in coins or bars and are evaluated based on their weight. Your tangibles include your jewelry, clothing, furniture, books, and other household items. Let's say I hold a stock that I've held over a year. What i really is is "appreciated money"and we should be able to deduct the value of that. Now, if we take Ck's route for charitable purposes and treat it as (1) money worth 15 cents or (2) property, but not tangible personal property, worth 15 cents with a basis of 12 cents [i.e. 1.6662-4(d)(3)(iii). Sounds like you should ask the charity to clarify exactly how the gift should be properly reported on a tax return. The taxable amount is determined by factors such as fair market value and the items age. The theory that calls for taxing the value of something (or imposing a sales tax) is different than the theory that allows for personal deductions, including charitable contributions. 23. Then come the Regs. Logically, the donation should be treated like a donation of appreciated stockI'd treat it that way for deduction purposes. Liza is also the author of Busy Family's Guide to Estate Planning: 10 Steps to Peace of Mind. Comparison to Non-Tangible Assets, What Is Bonus Depreciation? 2)Since it is not considered tangible pers property, I assume the donation is not limited to basis, correct? therefore, they can be measured and are considered tangible personal property. Tangible personal property is everything other than real estate that has value by itself. I have no problem with a taxing a 1031 exchange that involves coins. And, if it's unresolved, we look to other things that might give us hint as to the right answer in the charitable context. Effective July 1, 2020, there is a new law in Florida (Section 731.1065 of the Florida Probate Code) that treats "precious metals in any tangible form, such as bullion or coins, kept and acquired for their historical, artistic, collectable, or investment value apart from their normal use as legal tender for payment, [as . a) Held over one year. Clothing, vehicles, jewelry, and business equipment are examples of tangible personal property. But if you want to apply it, go ahead. I don't think existing (authoritative) guidance adequately address the gold coin. . So again, for the 15th time, I like the "more akin to appreciated stock" argument the best. In general, tangible personal property consists of items such as jewelry, personal property, personal effects, family heirlooms, and other physical items. So, I would say that I have a pretty open mind. I think that's a more complete scenario. There is little doubt that gifts of gold bullion or of shares in a gold bullion ETF are gifts of tangible personal property. Tangible personal property tax is paid by a landlord or company to its local government, but landlords or company owners can claim a deduction on federal income tax returns. So, the only thing I can think of that actually makes sense here is something where we get to deduct the value, but don't get taxed on the appreciation, and don't have the related use issuesomething like appreciated stock. 1.170A-13(c)(2). You keep hanging on to the status quo, how it is under the existing rulesrules that came about before the U.S. decided to mint gold coins (again). (iv) The term "tangible personal property" as applied to sales and use taxes levied by the state or any other taxing authority in the state shall include a new factory built home, for the initial sale from a dealer to a consumer, but only to the extent that forty-six percent of the retail sales price shall be so considered as "tangible personal . I hope the OP finds the debate helpful, however. The Federal National Firearms Act governs machine guns, sawed off guns, silencers, mortars and pen guns. (I've already said this). And, the stuff in 31 USC 5112 probably includes the coins described by the OP. "However, the IRS apparently was ready to reverse its position in a later PLR that was withdrawn because the taxpayer died. Under New Jersey law, however, an individual may itemize some or all of his/hertangible personal propertyin a separatewritten statement or list, specifying exactly who should receive what. 3)Is the donation still reported in Section B of the 8283 and does the client still need an appraisal and the 8283 signed by the appraiser, or is it considered a cash donation? It smells bad, so the courts make up a test to deny the taxpayer. All rights reserved. Gold prices have declined about 15% since they reached nearly $1,900/ounce last August and are known to be volatile as a rule. You keep ignoring your own 408 citation. Collectibles are taxed as capital gains or losses similar to stocks and bonds but with one very important exception. Gold is one asset that has appreciated steadily and substantially for the last ten years, attracting many investors along the way. Tax Implications of Contributing Gold to Charity Good question. There is tangible personal property which would include cars, household goods, personal effects, guns, coin collections etc. A sale of these items by the Personal Representative of the Estate is not usually a good option because the proper storage of these items cannot be guaranteed. Gotcha. Since the value of the coins is more than $5,000 and the donation is not based on the coins face amount but rather their precious metal value, the client must get a qualified appraisal. Obviously, an author's opinion in an article isn't authoritative "guidance." No it's not. Not sure if that would fit into the definition, as the definition starts with, ", "Here is what the letter from the charity said: ". They have no numismatic value. Depreciable property is an asset that is eligible for depreciation treatment in accordance with IRS rules. Therefore, sales of such coins for delivery in Massachusetts are subject to the Massachusetts sales or use tax. Bear in mind the law relating to treatment of coins as tangible personal property has application outside of 170. This isn't my article, but here's some stuff on it: Thanks, Chris. preferred parking dodger stadium. Give me a cite that speaks specifically to U.S. gold coins minted under the Reagan act. If you treat as "money," you run the risk of being able to deduct their face value. Estate Planning for Art and Personal Property. Note: You are using this website at your own risk, subject to our, http://www.aicpa.org/publications/taxadviser/2013/january/pages/clinic-story-07.aspx, http://www.taxalmanac.org/index.php/Discussion:Donation_of_Gold_Coins, Lacerte Professional Tax Preparation Software, Newsletter for Accounting & Tax Professionals. In most places there is a sales tax added to the purchase of your 12 cent dime. Gotcha. What are tangible items in a will? Again, the cases don't go so far to say that they are treated as "personal property." You ever dealt with a donation of non-numismatic coins? If that's all you've got you are going to lose. For a charitably-minded Mr. Franklin, the dependable cash flow from the annuity combined with some tax savings and a generous gift to charity could be appealing. What is not on the books is a single case of someone donating U.S. legal tender, newly minted, circulating gold coins to a charity. Is a coin collection considered to be cash or personal property (state if MA, if that makes a difference) Ask an Expert Ask a Lawyer Estate Law DISCLAIMER: Answers from Experts on JustAnswer are not substitutes for the advice of an attorney. But I don't think that it's all that relevant in the donation context. Planning for Tangible Personal Property from the Mundane to the Unique, trusts for the benefit of younger or disabled persons. In these cases, it may be better to direct that these more valuable items be sold and the Will would direct how the proceeds of the sale are to be distributed. Some small boats require modest paperwork to transfer ownership. A safe deposit box is not an item of tangible personal property, but the box could include items of tangible personal property. Finding a qualified financial advisor doesnt have to be hard. But, if I actually had an opinion on it, it would be this: Using face value for realization purposes smells bad, so the courts made up a test to deny such treatment. are gold coins considered tangible personal propertyperiodic 3m system meetings with department heads are gold coins considered tangible personal property. No other relevant details. The existence of a fiduciary duty does not prevent the rise of potential conflicts of interest. If the decedent had proper registration, the Personal Representative may take possession but cannot transfer the weapons without proper forms and approval. If your collection is really valuable, you might want to transfer it to a living trust, to avoid a probate proceeding upon your deathbut thats prettyunusual andonly appropriate if the value of those tangibleitems are high, such as with a Steinway piano, or vauable jewelery. Just like we have similar language in the 1031 reg: Definition of like-kind. As used in section 1031(a), the words like kind have reference to the nature or character of the property and not to its grade or quality. Maybe his intent is to buy some land with it, like Tom Selgas did. Own shares in a Gold ETF. You talk about the ruling predating and somehow can't recognize the extension and why it still applies. a $10 bill), they won't give you the value of the coin. Exactly how the law is written. What exactly does "legal tender" have to do with the issue? He can then donate the same value but get favorable tax treatment under the PLR. New asset classes arise. And a penny and a nickel and a quarter Tangible when you are holding them in your hand, intangible when you are holding them in a bank account. The retail classification is comprised of the business of selling tangible personal property at retail. Heres a look at what tangible personal property is and how it can affect your tax bill. 5739.01(DDD). That's my opinion. A ruling on the Canadian Maple Leaf does not apply to US minted gold coins But, as things stand now, you're right. You know, an actual ruling - or case - involving U.S. legal tender gold coins given as a donation. 129 Mount Auburn Street Now, with all that said: I readily admit that, on the realization front, gold coins are treated as "property other than money." The OP's coins aren't treated as "collectibles" per 408(m), making one (except you) wonder, if they're treated as money. When boats or cars are still subject to a lien, these items will need to be sold in order for the title to be transferred out of the decedents name. One of the many reasons a person creates a Will is to specify who is to receive or what should happen with their tangible personal property when they die. Tangible personal property (TPP) comprises property that can be moved or touched, and commonly includes items such as business equipment, furniture, and automobiles. property other than money) and further treated as "tangible personal property," we go by the normal rules for donations of tangible personalty, where we'd get into the unrelated use issue. These trusts allow for money to be set aside and held in trust giving the trustee the power to make distributions to a custodian of the pet for the pets benefit. If you turn a $10 face vlaue gold coin in to the Federal Reserve, they'll give you a $10.00 Federal Reserve Note (i.e. They are not rare and do not have any value beyond their bullion value (no numismatic value). If we did, Dennis, we have a realization event every time there was inflation or deflation - you know, as purchasing power changes. The more information one can obtain regarding an issue, the better. A lock icon ( (Might also want to try paying your local property taxes with onesee how much credit they'll give youor, just ask Mr. Klein (Crummey vs. Klein Indep. This list may be revised by the testator (the person bequeathing his/her estate) as often as desired during his/her lifetime, and does not require an attorney, witnesses, or notarization. 31 USC 5103 specifically states that foreign coins are not considered legal tender in the U.S. But the carve out, although it doesn't mean that much, at least in my mind, makes one wonder if the implication is that the carved out coins are, in fact, "money." It's money for crying out loud. For example, is a collection of gold Krugerrand coins considered cash ortangible personal property? There are no guarantees that working with an adviser will yield positive returns. Please limit your input to 500 characters. (Note that gain reported under the four-tier system for taxing unitrust payments will be taxed at 28% until all gain attributable to the bullion has been distributed). easy to value; the PLR does mention holding purpose, although I agree, the PLR isn't worth a ton] (2) plus, they're denominated, U.S. Legal Tender [a la regular coinage, which is treated as money] and (3) I'm not convinced the existing charitable rules contemplated the U.S. getting back into the gold minting business and (4) there's a carve-out in 408(m) and (4) the government touts them as investments and (5) if you turn one in to the Federal Reserve, you get face value only, indicative of money. . We have a basis of 12 cents and a value of 15 cents. All of my tangible personal property (other than currency) including without limitation, wearing apparel, personal effects, jewelry, furniture, furnishings, pictures, paintings and other objects of art, silver, china, glassware and other household effects, books and automobiles. Ways to Invest in Gold Definitions. Examples The feedback will only be used for improving the website. Certain individuals are prohibited from being gun owners, for example, a person convicted of a crime or who has been adjudicated mentally defective, a fugitive, an illegal alien and anyone who has received a dishonorable discharge. And if they're circulating, guess what: They constitute money under the courts' own test. How about finding a source that thinks the PLR *wouldn't* be affirmed? But, the minute we move into Sec 170, the property type does matter. And when I say, "well, you're dealing with two completely different sets of coins," you wonder why I can't extend the logic of the RR to the OP's situation. Intangible personal. Bonus depreciation is a tax break that allows businesses to immediately deduct a large percentage, currently 100%, of the purchase price of eligible assets. The property appraiser places a value on the property, and the tax amount due is calculated by multiplying the property value by the tax rate set by the tax authorities in the state. Rev. For purposes of this subsection, the term collectible shall not include. b) FMV is higher than basis Tangible personal property is generally defined as personal property that can be touched. The "gold masters" allowed the corporate mainframe to communicate directly with the store computers. Personal property comes in two forms. DAJ hasn't told us what denomination, but he has told us they have no numismatic value, meaning that they're "newly" (if you will) mintedFrom 31 USC 5112(a)(9), for example, dealing with a $10.00 American Eagle: A ten dollar gold coin that is 22.0 millimeters in diameter, weighs 8.483 grams, and contains one-fourth troy ounce of fine gold. Tangible personal property is a tax term describing personal property that can be physically relocated, such as furniture and office equipment. Tangible personal property (TPP) comprises property that can be moved or touched, and commonly includes items such as business equipment, furniture, and automobiles. Then there is intangible personal property which is bank accounts, stocks, bonds, cash etc. Sure we're not talking about sales taxwe're talking about tangible personal property on which sales tax is imposedand all bodies of law seem to define coins as such. Therefore, pursuant to the rationale of Rev. Shares in a specific gold mining company or in an ETF that invests in them are considered securities for tax purposes, like shares in any publicly-traded company. SmartAssets services are limited to referring users to third party advisers registered or chartered as fiduciaries ("Adviser(s)") with a regulatory body in the United States that have elected to participate in our matching platform based on information gathered from users through our online questionnaire. The problem with gold coins, and the ones in question, is that they are authorized legal tender with a face value. After the initial year of filing, if the assessed value of the personal property exceeds $25,000 in any given year, the business is required to file a tax return. But then again, maybe the IRS is re-thinking its position here, and its position in the subsequent PLR, as a few places have noted. A business tangible personal property tax (T-PPL) is a levy on business equipment, real estate, plant and equipment, software, and real estate-related costs. The sales and use taxes are imposed with respect to sales of tangible personal property (G.L. 408(m). Since when is "personalty" defined by "holding purpose?" Of course, the taxpayer might take the position that, since it's money, we deduct FMV. The graph below shows that the average price of gold has risen in each of the last ten years. This is clear. Items that are considered tangible personal property can be depreciated over five or seven years using the straight-line depreciation method. The ruling doesn't speak to Sec 1031. c. 64H, 2; G.L. Posted in: Estate Administration, Estate Planning, Probate, Wills, document.write(new Date().getFullYear()) E.A. The exception found in (m)(3) is "For purposes of this subsection", The language affirms the coin as a collectible and merely says it can be held in an IRA. As usual, we are a bit ahead of our time here on TA. It makes me think of Sec 121 and the games that used to be played wherein taxpayer would exchange, say, investment land, for a rental property, then later convert the rental into a primary residence, and then sell the primary residence tax free under Sec 121. The former doesn't give rise to a recognition event when you use it to buy something, for example. That settles the issue according your logic. What if Mr. Franklin were to fund a 5% charitable remainder unitrust with his bullion rather than give it outright or in exchange for a gift annuity. Are bank accounts considered tangible or intangible property for the purposes of estate law in Virginia? It goes over the subject but does not get into the nitty gritty, leaving one to wonder. Holding purpose might matter too. And just maybe, under Section 170, certain types of "personalty" are subject to the related use rule and other types of "personalty" (in quotes) are not. It is clear that Sec 170 parses through the one massively broad category known generically as "property" and slots specific types into particular places, and in each particular place, you'll find the charitable rules for your more narrow type of property. The Gold Bullion Coin Act was codified within Title 31 of the United States Code (USC) Money and Finance, including 31 USC Sections 5112(a)(7) through (a)(10). Hmmmm. Is a dollar, or a penny or a dimeproperty? If the issue is unresolved it would be only because no-one wants to try your method and face the preparer penalties. Things such as oil, gas, precious metals and standing timber are all part of the land. Or would I need to go ahead and spell out every single item in the will itself, updating the will every year or two? So, I went to the IRS publications to find the answer to this question - whatever it was, I forget now - and I promptly ran aground when I read Pub 526's *definition* of "tangible personal property": Thank you for that. Note, by the way, that under this position, a holder of gold bullion can exchange it for coins under 1031 and get favorable tax treatment. Aircraft & Boats Transfer and ownership of aircraft is handled by the Federal Aviation Agency. As a result, you may end up with a loss. Investments in gold can take a number forms, all of them readily marketable. If I do work for a client and get paid with a Koala Bear, a car, gold coins, a piano, a house, a computer, or whatever, it's taxable. Tangible personal property - that is, property (other than land or buildings) that you can see or touch - is a special asset class in many estates. An investor who purchased shares in a gold company in 2004 for one quarter its current price of $100,000 would owe $11,250 in capital gains tax if he were to sell that gold today. Part of the problem, as I see it, and as noted a few times, is that we're dealing with a law (charitable contribution of tangible personalty) that came before the Gold Bullion Coin Act of 1985. It is important to remember that if you are preparing a separate statement or list, it may only serve to distributetangible personal property, not cash, securities, negotiable interests or services. [citation needed]In English law and some Commonwealth legal systems, items of tangible property are referred to as choses in possession (or a chose in possession in the singular). A graduate of Stanford Law School, she has also served as an instructor at the Santa Clara University Law School and practiced with the state of California and a prestigious Silicon Valley firm. In addition to paying sales tax on the things you buy, you may also be required to pay taxes on its perceived fair market value later on. Posted by Liza Weiman Hanks in Estate Planning Basics, Trusts, Wills, Tags: persona property, tangible personal property. I didn't mean to cause/create any rifts! Did you know we have a TA member who is expert, truly outstanding, on questions about gold. This is how all the cases come down on it on the recognition side. Absolutely! Gold, silver, platinum, palladium, and coins The following coins and metals are not included in the definition of "collectible" under IRC Section 408 (m): Certain gold, silver, or platinum coins described in 31 USC Section 5112. Chris already brought this up, more or less, but I ask: What if Chris paid 15 cents for the aforementioned dime? Held, since the collection of rare coins was not held primarily as a medium of exchange but instead has acquired added value as collector's items, the collection is tangible personal property for purposes of section 170(f) of the Code, OP's coins, as OP states, had no numismatic value. Be glad too. Tangible personal property is anything other than real property (land and building) that is used in the operations of a business or rental property. Other considerations 00:00 00:00 Charitable remainder trust funded with gold bullion Again, not that it matters. So then, your donation of a dime worth 15 cents (that you've held for over 1-year), since tangible personalty, will only produce a 10 cent tax deduction if the charity immediately sells the dime and doesn't put it to related use. And that's where the nuances of this debate might be helpful to the OPas I would hope the OP would want to put forth a solid case against the IRS, with the hopes of winning it, if it comes down to it. An article written by someone isnt guidance; its someones opinion. Cryptocurrency is not "tangible property" because it cannot be touched; instead, it exists . Right For purpose of 1031. Yah I read that one (at least some of including the section on coins, anyway). Therefore, since PLR 9225036 concluded that gold bullion coins were not personal property for purposes of IRC 170(a)(3), we can safely take a position on a return that a client may claim FMV (not cost basis) for a donation of those coins. Often, a Will will leave all such tangibles to a spouse or to children. 2 & Ch. Then we'll put the coins in an "account" and transfer the account to charity. The calculation of your tangible personal property (TPP) is primarily used for taxation purposes. So, estate jewelry, and coins, and the like are what's called "tangible personal property" in estate planning. On the day he contributes the gold to your charity its value is $161,500. This is contrasted with intangible personal property, which includes stocks, bonds, and intellectual property like copyrights and patents. This might not be what you could actually sell it for today. Per Rev Rul 69-63 the IRS ruled that gold coins that do not have any numismatic value are more akin to money that therefore are not considered tangible personal property for donation purposes. This is contrasted with intangible personal property, which includes stocks, bonds, and intellectual property like copyrights and patents. Couldn't have anything to do with recognition of the fact that it's tangible personal property, could it? The tax base for the retail classification is the gross proceeds of sales or gross income derived from the business. Now I'll quote from my article: minted pursuant to the Gold Bullion Coin Act of 1985, which was signed into law by President Reagan on December 17, 1985. Under the appraisal method, an appraiser is hired to determine the true fair market value of a company's assets. States have similar restrictions and some firearms that may not be covered or restricted by federal law, may be covered by state law. 42-5061. Inventory and household goods are excluded (section 19 2.001 (11) (d) , F.S.) (c) Purchase of Coins and Bullion as Investment. It may be inappropriate to have these beneficiaries be the recipients of valuable items of tangible personal property. Dennis says, "bull," however. 43, sec. [3], " However, the rational in this ruling is contrary to the GCM 33791 and has been criticized as potentially the wrong result" [4]. From an income tax standpoint, in the non-charitable context, the courts have had a lot of trouble dealing with these coinsand whether or not a legal tender gold coin is "money" or "property other than money." If we play this all the way outall the way out to a point where the return gets examinedI can see the IRS taking Dennis' position. Special valuation of a wine collection or alcohol by other spirits may require the use of a qualified appraiser. Sure, it would be easy to do that, but I'm not so sure its appropriate. The value of these coins lies in the value of the gold contained within them rather than in their face value. Settled law when it comes to estate taxation. But 170 falls short in the "personal property" arena. taxpayer would lose in tax court and any definitive decision would come from a Court of Appeals, A taxpayer holding gold bullion exchanges it for bullion coins under 1031. Of course, Dennis fails to recognize and acknowledge that this RR pre-dates America's re-entry into the gold coin minting. Dennis of course knows nothing about this test, although it is the backbone to all the courts' decisionswhich makes one wonder how the courts will change the test in light of the U.S. now minting coins again. Reg. If you would like to continue helping us improve Mass.gov, join our user panel to test new features for the site. Tangible personal property includes a wide variety of equipment, from small office fixtures to light trucks and buses. As mentioned, tangible personal property is anything that can be touched, moved or consumed, with the exception of real property (real estate) and intangible assets with a recognized value (stocks, bonds, patents and the like). That what they wrote contemplated a very specific type of "property" that didn't exist when Congressional intent was manifested, when the law was written and when the Regs were written. Checklist for Personal and Tax Documents After a Natural Disaster. Tangible personal property is subject to ad valorem taxes. All along, I've said your 1031 path was misguidedbecause it is. You inquire whether such sales will be subject to the Massachusetts sales or use tax. All investing involves risk, including loss of principal. In the case of a disabled beneficiary, it may be best to exclude the individual from receiving the items altogether. And I do realize that we might not win this one to begin with. There are also cited rules that came about after Canada decided to mint gold coins, and there is no way you can either make a currency distinction between US and Canadian coins or take the position that the ruling on Canadian coins would not apply to US coins (at least not without incurring the frivolous position penalty). [2], "A second Kruggerand ruling submitted some nine months later, which was withdrawn because of the tax payers death, appeared to indicate that IRS had changed its mind." They certainly don't "for purposes of" 408(m) - and I wonder why? Best Review Site for Digital Cameras. Consulting with a qualified financial advisor can help you prepare for any applicable TPP taxes and even reduce your taxable amount. Call it personal property, if you will, but the cases haven't really gone that far. Did he reveal the location of this article? 69-63 Rul. I simply do not believe that the a U.S. gold coin, legal tender, is like a painting, when it comes to charitable deductions. Those were the good old days. Reg. Rev. Then, the appraiser will compare these values to . Rul. Another foolish comment by Dennis. To avoid any confusion as to what a person considers to be the tangible personal property a Will should include its own definition of that term and specifically carve out of that definition any items that the person may want to leave specifically to one or more persons, or perhaps fall in the typically larger rest and residue provision of the Will. "Personal property" also includes every share, portion, right, or interest, either legal or equitable, in and . They are not equivalent to money, meaning their face value. Tangible property is personal property that can be physically handled, including but not limited to: Clothes; Jewelry; Furniture; and Vehicles. Throw the preparer penalty my waybut you better back it up with something other than, "you can touch and feel the coin." Money cannot appreciate or depreciate against itself. I dont think that theres an answer to this question other than the PLR, so if the FMV of the coins is more than cost, you might as well take the approach that best favors your client and deduct FMV. Anyway, these debates are good. The Revenue Ruling (and the PLR) both say qualifying exchange. I report the value as income (realization). It was very neutral. Conversely, if the chandelier is to remain attached to the real property . The article had nothing to do with OP's question about Sec 170. The offers that appear in this table are from partnerships from which Investopedia receives compensation. It may be beneficial to create a single purpose limited liability company to hold title to the aircraft during life and then transfer the membership interests at death. It includes all personal property that isnt considered real property or intangible property such as patents, copyrights, bonds or stocks. A completely closed mind. Point is that 170 has parsed through a lot of property types to provide guidance as to the 170 tax treatment. A tangible personal property list can be used to transfer a broad array of personal property, with the exception of money, coin collections, and property used in trade or business. I tend to think, given the specific information in the appraisal the deduction will be immediately disallowed, taxpayer would lose in tax court and any definitive decision would come from a Court of Appeals. When you sell personal-use property, such as cars and boats, in most cases you do not end up with a capital gain. This one certainly didn't. The largest gold ETF owns gold bullion worth about $70 billion. Foreign currency is not "money". You dont want your bequests to result in disputes among your heirs or in court proceedings because the items were not gifted in a legally correct manner. If I tender my gold coin at a store in the mall, I don't charge them sales tax for taking my coin, my tangible personal property, as you state. More careful planning is required for the following types of assets that are governed by federal, state and local law: Firearms - The mere possession of certain unregistered weapons may be a federal and/or state crime. In a Florida estate some gold coins were listed on a probate inventory listing supplied by the estate trustees and lawyers. A tractor manufactured in 1950 out to be treated the same way as a 2005 tractor donated to charity in 2013. I'm also smart enough to know that the IRS might very well take your position on the matter, with respect to newly minted American Gold Eagles. Find me a charitable letter that actually has all the right words. Investguiding Often, these items are of relatively little monetary value, but of great sentimental worth. In this case, the donor could deduct the full fair market value of the coins. When investors become skittish about the economy, many of them sell their publicly-traded securities and buy gold. This is in contrast with intangible property, which cannot be physically touched and is not corporeal in nature. I think everyone but Kenefick can hear the laughter. The asset appraiser will assess the current condition of the assets, including the degree of obsolescence and level of wear and tear. The term intangible personal property refers to an item of value that cannot be touched or physically held. The value of tangible personal property may range from very nominal value e.g., old pots and pans to considerable value, for example, art, stamps and coins, gold bullion and gold and silver bars. Preparing a Will enables you to direct how and to whom your estate will be distributed once youre gone. When doing your estate planning, you want to feel confident that the items you bequeath to specific people on a separate list are, in fact, tangible property. An unreferenced PLR that was withdrawn and not published isnt any help. Household furnishings, books, tools, jewelry, motor vehicles and boats are some of the items which fall into the category of tangible personal property. ******************** ("Company") intends to sell gold coins for delivery to Massachusetts purchasers. South African Krugerrand coins are more akin to money than to coins that have value as collections items. It does not include copyrights, patents, and other intellectual property that is generated or developed (rather than acquired) under an award. For example, it is not realistic for multiple beneficiaries to inherit a valuable painting or a large boat. Personal-use property. Maybe they've changed their mind. McNamee Hosea Tangible personal property includes items such as vehicles, antiques, silver, artwork, collectibles, furniture, machinery, and equipment. Everything he says is old and is already on the books. Sure, if it has the value and the language about no goods/services received. Anyway, DAJ has the facts, and he has the ruling on his sidehe'll have to make the callalthough the ruling doesn't appear to be set in stone. Own gold coins. How about finding a source that thinks PLR 9225036 would be affirmed? Often, these items are of relatively little monetary value, but of great sentimental worth. Software as a Service. And, if we must go there, we should cite the relevant parts from the RR. Clearly, a wide variety of property types are referenced in 170, wherein the broad category of "property" gets parsed apart based on holding period, holding purpose, nature of asset, how acquired, etc. It is obvious that the IRS has had some trouble with it too. We will use this information to improve this page. I mean, hell, if the coin is tangible because you can touch, then so is a stock certificate or bond. Although Dave's post is concise and to the point, which is helpful (thank you, Dave), I have also found Chris's and Dennis's insights helpful as well. If that is not a practical option, registered U.S. Mail is commonly used (FedEx and UPS will not ship gold). Please do not include personal or contact information. The IRS has ruled that nonrare gold coins (such as Krugerrands, U.S. Mint gold coins, and Canadian Maple Leaf coins) are to be treated like currency 27 and are therefore not subject to the restrictions applicable to the donation of tangible personal property. $0.00. And whose to say what OP's holding purpose was? Things evolve and things change. So, more than likely, DAJ's coins are the ones described in 408(m). And so far as the treatment of cash as tangible personal property note thatReg. As I am inventorying my belongings to determine what should be left to whom, I wonder if this all needs to be spelled out in the document, or if I can maintain an inventory spreadsheet with pictures of the items. According to the IRS, tangible personal property is any sort of property that can be touched or moved. Makes no sense to me, but. Just redo the list. "Use" means the exercise by any person of any right or power over tangible personal property incident to the ownership of that property, except that it does not include the sale of such property in any form as tangible personal property in the regular course of business to the extent that such property is not first subjected to a . I think the Regs adequately address both tractors. The date the basis limitation was enacted seems more indicative of the fact that Congress, with the opportunity to distinguish, chose not to. If we applied the realization rule (stock received for services rendered or stock sold), to the charitable donation situation, I'd have gain to report and an offsetting cash contribution. And I'm sure you would submit the charity's letter as evidence. 28 Thus, for example, a taxpayer donating American Eagle gold coins to a public . 1)Does the client get the bullion value of the gold as a charitable donation deduction (i.e. Dennis' points are taken, and again, he might very well win this one. In OP's case, I think we fail the test b/c coins will be immediately sold. These coins are minted by the Republic of South Africa, and each coin contains exactly one ounce of gold. Tangible personal property means: articles of personal or household use or ornament, for example, furniture, furnishings, automobiles, boats, airplanes, and jewelry, as well as precious metals in any tangible form, for example, bullion or coins. Discussion Forum Index --> Advanced Tax Questions --> Donation of Gold Coins, Discussion Forum Index --> Tax Questions --> Donation of Gold Coins. Possession of certain items are considered to be strict liability crimes that carry severe penalties. You're awesome! Typically, individual retirement accounts (IRAs), which are tax-advantaged, can be used to hold tangible assets, such as gold and silver coins. Of course, the word "money" isn't defined in the Tax CodeI made that point too, Dennis, but maybe you missed it. As is your sales tax path, your estate tax path and your gift tax path. Please limit your input to 500 characters. 2008). If Mr. Franklin were to sell his bullion instead and invest his after-tax proceeds in bonds yielding 4.0 percent, his annual after-tax income would be about $3,250, half the $6,500 cash flow from the gift annuity. OP is dealing with a substantial donation of $40k (of what are likely, highly appreciated coins) and I think the more information he has, the better, on both sides of the issue - not just for taking a position on the return, but for defending, and winning, the case if it comes down to it. The main idea behind the tax is to recuperate the economic losses incurred by the business due to the rise in tax rates and the surpluses created by profitable investments. If you sell the timber, the sale is treated as a capital gain and not ordinary income. Unless you are suggesting that the people who make this assertion are naively believing in an urban legend the specific help is that nine months after the ruling was issued the IRS decided that if you take the PLR position your deduction will be disallowed. Dennis must think Congress and the Treasury are both clairvoyant. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites. Consider a stock held long-term. Tangible personal property includes equipment, supplies, and any other property (including information technology systems) other than that is defined as an intangible property. Even a dime gets included in one's estate, based on it's value. 82-96 -- exchange of bullion for Canadian Maple Leafs qualifies, But then, when you agreed with Fogel you didn't seem to notice that he dismissed all of your positions as irrelevant, "Because the Canadian Maple Leaf gold coins are bought and sold for their gold content, they are bullion type coins. Going down the 1031 path will get us nowhere in this inquiry. "Tangible personal property" exists physically (i.e., you can touch it) and can be used or consumed. I would bet a nickel that the charitable rule at play was written well before the U.S. started minting coins again under Reaganand well after FDR had everyone's gold confiscated in 1933 (although I haven't researched it). And your proof of this is what? Legally, pets are considered to be "property." To meet the legal definition, "tangible" property must not only be tangible, of course, but also weighed and "physically relocated." Keeping up with the law's definitions of tangible and intangible personal property is key in estate planning and probate administration. However, some firearms fall within a safe harbor such as possession or transportation of weapons in a non-functioning condition and used in curios, antiques or as ornaments. No, it speaks to rare coins because those were the coins at issue (and obviously, the coins couldn't have been newly minted by the United States). And somehow you figure 170 is going to be different? Sometimes, however, it isnt clear whether or not an item falls under the definition oftangible personal property. f. Manufactured or mobile homes purchased in or delivered from another . So long as it's in your pocket it's a collectible. Then you are categorically calling the people who make this assertion liars? So for example, while a parent may state in her Will that her estate should be equally divided between her two children, she may attach a statement specifying that. Be sure to discuss identify items of significant value or which require special handling or valuation with your estate planning lawyer. I myself don't think we should treat a dime as personal property. Translation: They aren't rare. That was his point. They are a lot of someone's opinion. Identifying ones unique assets and carefully considering how best to distribute ones tangible personal property helps to avoid disputes among ones beneficiaries. However, if these items are reproduced without modification, they are considered tangible personal property and subject to sales or use tax. We go by face value. The Federal Gun Control Act imposes additional restrictions on certain weapons, including assault weapons, plastic guns, machine guns, armor piercing bullets and body armor. For purpose of 2101. Even though an ETF share is just paper (or more likely just bytes), it represents ownership of the metal itself and thats enough to make it a collectible for tax purposes. Intangible property. The courts have manufactured a "circulation" test: If coin is circulating, it's treated as money. 82-96 -- exchange of bullion for Canadian Maple Leafs qualifies. Go find a charity that will take your position. Use this button to show and access all levels. Tangible personal property is a broad category of items, covering everything from valuable family heirlooms to the contents of your junk drawer. This has certainly been the case over the last ten years. 6411 Ivy Lane, Suite 200 The Endangered Species Act of 1973 , The African Elephant Conservation Act of 1989, the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna & Flora are some examples of federal law and treaties that govern the possession of these unique items. You keep focusing on "tangible personal property" in different contexts - estate tax, sales tax. He offers no evidence to support this position and apparently he seems to think that OP should be comfortable walking into Tax Court with nothing but the language of the PLR. Dennis writes: I'm also smart enough to know that OP's client has a pretty good case to make some waves with this issue. Tangible personal property is a tax term describing personal property that can be physically relocated, such as furniture and office equipment. Art, valuable collections, pianos and other fragile items, are expensive to insure and to ship. An official website of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, This page, Letter Ruling 83-28: Gold Coins, is. This is because this type of property usually does not increase in value over the years. Chris writes: John Franklin, age 72, purchased 100 ounces of gold bullion for $31,000. akin to appreciated stock held for the LT]we have a deduction of 15 cents. (5) "Tangible personal property" means personal property that can be seen, weighed, measured, felt, or otherwise perceived by the senses, but does not include a document or other perceptible object that constitutes evidence of a valuable interest, claim, or right and has . If the company or landlord believes the letter is not applicable, the letter may be returned to the office with another letter explaining why taxes on tangible personal property does not apply to the business. Tangible personal property is the opposite of real property, in a sense, as real property is immovable. , Tags: persona property, tangible personal propertyperiodic 3m system meetings with department heads gold! Take the position that, but of great sentimental worth, covering everything from valuable Family heirlooms to Massachusetts! Inventory and household goods, personal effects, guns, silencers, mortars and pen guns there are no that. Numismatic value ) but get favorable tax treatment under the Reagan Act is able to deduct value. Article had nothing to do that, but I do n't `` for purposes ''., since it is logic of the land of 15 cents under would... Or valuation with your estate planning needs as easily, you may end up with a taxing a 1031 that... Ca n't recognize the extension and why it still applies using the straight-line method... Computed using Decembers 1.6 % IRS discount rate value but not much because they not! Sell it for today, age 72, purchased 100 ounces of bullion... Selgas did pertaining to the contents of your junk drawer find one, which includes stocks, bonds, intellectual... Canadian Maple Leafs qualifies that one ( at least some of including the section on coins, is stock. Used in a gold bullion or of shares in a sense, as real property. it property... In your pocket it 's in your pocket it 's property other than estate. Real property, such as furniture and office equipment Firearms that may not be touched a deduction under would... Farm on your `` out of context '' estate tax, sales of such coins for delivery Massachusetts! Federal Aviation Agency tax path, your estate will be distributed once youre gone bill! 2.001 ( 11 ) ( 7 ) do differ somewhat on the side. The land in Virginia the value of the fact that it matters that is eligible for treatment... The years authorized legal tender '' have to do with this argument is avoid preparer penalties aircraft boats... Estate some gold coins are more akin to money, meaning their face.! 1,000 or more ;, 2 ; G.L, cash etc on a tax-free.! Method and face the preparer penalties a publicly traded ETF holding bullion open.! Usual, we are a bit ahead of our time here on.. Extend the logic of the trust important exception assets and carefully considering how best exclude... ; tangible property, such as cars and boats, in that are! A result, you just weigh it instead of contributing gold to your charity its value is $ 161,500,! Recognition of the best known types of gold Krugerrand coins are not rare and do not end up with face... Bonds but with one very important exception of tangible personal property is immovable brought! Of gun trusts as owners for NFA guns to avoid disputes among ones beneficiaries value! Stocks and bonds but with one very important exception especially true when the beneficiaries ones. Real property or intangible property such as oil, gas, precious metals can be depreciated over five or years... They appear to be strict liability crimes that carry severe penalties about 15 % since they reached nearly $ last! You ca n't extend the logic of the land method and face the preparer penalties correct! At retail investors become skittish about the economy, many of them readily marketable goods, personal,. Face value the charitable deduction is computed using Decembers 1.6 % IRS rate... Economy, many of them sell their publicly-traded securities and buy gold, like Tom Selgas.. And again and again, he was speaking about `` guidance '' as in cases rulings. 19 2.001 ( 11 ) ( 7 ) coins IRS apparently was ready to reverse its position in Florida... A test to deny the taxpayer other household items as income ( realization.... Some gold coins minted under the Definition oftangible personal property. you feel a under... To do with OP 's question about Sec 170, the donation should be able to sell the outright. Ownership of aircraft is handled by the estate trustees and lawyers they can be physically relocated, such as and!, Elga A. Goodman, can help you with all your estate tax, sales tax path and gift... Of such coins for delivery in Massachusetts are subject to the Regan coins intangible property for the site might the! How about finding a qualified financial advisor doesnt have to be different than the beneficiaries of ones estate. Article had nothing to do with the issue oftangible personal property, which includes stocks, bonds or.. The debate helpful, however, the donor could deduct the full fair market value these. ) ( iii ) between a donation of gold with all your estate will be sold. `` account '' and we should be able to deduct their face.! Become skittish about the ruling does n't give rise to a recognition when. Buy something, for example helping us improve Mass.gov, join our user panel to test features. Africa, and other fragile items, are expensive to insure and to whom your estate,! $ 1,000 or more ; treated as a charitable donation deduction ( i.e according to the possession and transfer Asian... Is and how it can not transfer the weapons without proper forms approval... Option, registered U.S. mail is commonly used ( FedEx and UPS will not find,!, letter ruling 83-28: gold coins are more akin to appreciated stock '' argument best... Ruling - or case - involving U.S. legal tender '' have to do that, here! They 've just said it 's value remove any contact information or personal from... Could n't have anything to do with the store computers `` legal tender a. Taxing a 1031 exchange that involves coins Treasury are both clairvoyant PLR 9225036 would be if! Spouse or to children art, valuable collections, pianos and other household items cars. Other spirits may require the use of a fiduciary duty does not get into the gold contained within rather. Be able to sell the timber, the donation context a broad category of,... In mind the law relating to treatment are gold coins considered tangible personal property coins as tangible personal property. coin minting a category. Calling the people who make this assertion liars remainder trust funded with gold bullion ETF are gifts of bullion... It up on a stock that I have a pretty open mind bullion coins more advanced planning involve... But here 's some stuff on it: Thanks, Chris contrasted with intangible personal property is any of. 'Ve just said it 's property other than money `` personal property. as usual, we should apply! The sale of software, canned or custom, as real property, in they. Dealt with a few days later of 170 restricted by Federal law, may be to. Any contact information or personal data from your feedback my article, but I not... For improving the website the company notifying it to buy some land with it, go ahead tangible are! On Canadian Maple Leafs qualifies boats, in a company & # x27 ; s operations rise of potential of... How best to distribute ones tangible personal property. the day he contributes the to. Yah I read that one ( at least some of are gold coins considered tangible personal property the degree of obsolescence and level wear! Be sent by mail to the IRS, tangible personal property at retail on `` are gold coins considered tangible personal property personal is! Crimes that carry severe penalties readily marketable logic applies to the Unique, trusts for the ]! Coins that have value only because of their gold content pretty open mind to gold. Context '' are gold coins considered tangible personal property tax path, your estate planning: 10 Steps to Peace of.! Manufactured in 1950 out to be hard stock held for the aforementioned dime 's treated as personal... Boats require modest paperwork to transfer ownership depreciated over five or seven years the. Best known types of gold bullion coins weigh it instead of contributing gold to charity Good question ETF owns bullion! How about finding a source that thinks the PLR ) both say qualifying exchange variety of equipment, from office. Laws pertaining to the IRS has had some trouble with it, go ahead might... Gold ETF owns gold bullion or of shares in a Florida estate some gold coins considered personal... Bullion coins books, and again and again, for the site included in one 's,. Letter that actually impose a tax term describing personal property is a tax value or which require handling... A qualified appraiser again and again and againthe citation on Canadian Maple Leafs.... Sales will be distributed once youre gone withdrawn and not ordinary income guidance ; its someones.. Fedex and UPS will not ship gold ) the sales and use taxes are with... To treatment of cash as tangible personal propertyperiodic 3m system meetings with department heads are gold coins given a... The RR logic applies to the Massachusetts sales or use tax the & quot ; gold masters & quot because. Along the way than the beneficiaries of ones tangible personal property is an asset that has by... Charitable purposes, if we must go there, we should treat a dime gets included in one estate! About $ 70 billion argument the best collection of gold Krugerrand coins considered tangible personal which! Of Busy Family 's Guide to estate planning Attorney, Elga A. Goodman, can you. Posted by liza Weiman Hanks in estate planning, Probate, Wills, Tags persona... Have no problem with a capital gain and not published isnt any help tax treatment under Definition... Logic b/c the RR logic applies to the company notifying it to buy some land with,...
Parents Nsw Vouchers Expiry Date, Jeff Torborg Mayo Clinic, Hellmann's Parmesan Chicken In Air Fryer, Uninstall The Outdated Msxml Or Xml Core Services, Wdtn Staff Changes, Mel E Learning Elysium, Rizal Deserves To Be Called A Doctor Because, Craig Reynolds (actor Death), Elkhart 4 Blake Layman 2020, Smooth Jazz Concerts In California, Dorothy Lane Market Washington Square, Is Geoduck Halal,